London · For photographers, filmmakers and brands
Real People vs AI in Advertising: What Audiences Trust, and Where Each Belongs
AI images are cheap, and audiences can tell. Getty data on trust, where AI fits and where it doesn't, the UK rules on beauty filters, and how to sell real work.
- Words and camera
- Joshua Swain
- Published
- Reading time
- 4 min
- Filed under
- Guide
In brief
- People don't reject AI outright; they reject being fooled by it.
- A useful rule: AI for ideas and objects, real people for anything a customer will believe.
- In the UK, the Advertising Standards Authority has told brands and influencers not to apply filters to images promoting beauty products if the filter is likely to exaggerate the product's effect.
- Behind-the-scenes clips, the make-up chair, the lighting set-up.
- The Waterproof editorial was planned around one line: anyone can generate a red lip, nobody can generate the person wearing it.
Contents 9 sections
AI images are fast and cheap, and audiences can increasingly tell. In Getty Images' research, nearly 90% of people want to know when an image was made with AI, and 98% say authentic images and video matter for trust. This guide is for photographers pitching against AI, and for brands deciding where AI helps and where only a real shoot will do.
Anyone can generate a face now. That's exactly why a real one is worth more.

What audiences actually say
The gap between those two numbers is the opportunity. People don't reject AI outright; they reject being fooled by it. A brand that shows a real person, a real product and a real result has something a generated image can't offer: proof.1
When AI helps, and when only a real shoot will do
| Job | AI is fine | Shoot it for real |
|---|---|---|
| Concept and moodboards | Yes, to explore a look quickly | |
| Backgrounds and set ideas | Yes, for planning and mock-ups | |
| Illustrations of objects and places | Yes, if labelled | |
| Faces, skin, hair | Yes. This is where trust is won or lost | |
| Beauty and skincare results | Yes. Claims must reflect the real product | |
| Product on a person | Yes. Fit, scale and texture have to be true | |
| Testimonials and people's stories | Always real |
A useful rule: AI for ideas and objects, real people for anything a customer will believe. On this blog, for example, the illustrations of kit and sets are AI and labelled as such; every face is a real person from a real shoot.
Filters and the UK advertising rules
In the UK, the Advertising Standards Authority has told brands and influencers not to apply filters to images promoting beauty products if the filter is likely to exaggerate the product's effect. That applies to AI retouching too. Cleaning a stray hair is fine; changing what the product appears to do is not.
Keep the texture
Retouch blemishes and stray hairs, but keep pores and skin texture. If the product is a foundation, the finish on screen must be the finish in real life.
Keep the before and after honest
Same light, same angle, same camera settings, and no filter on either frame.
How to sell real work in the AI era

Show the process
Behind-the-scenes clips, the make-up chair, the lighting set-up. A BTS film is the simplest proof that a person was really there.
Credit everyone
Model, make-up, hair, stylist, agency. A full credit list is something no generated image has.
Keep the RAW files
Original camera files with their metadata show where and when an image was made. Keep them, and offer them if a client needs proof.
Use AI where it saves time
Moodboards, concept frames, planning. Then shoot the real thing. Clients care about the result, and real people are the result.
Waterproof: a shoot built around "real"

The Waterproof editorial was planned around one line: anyone can generate a red lip, nobody can generate the person wearing it.
A real model, real water on the skin, a lipstick that genuinely didn't move, and a behind-the-scenes film where the model tells the story herself. The retouching cleaned the frame but kept every pore. That combination is the whole pitch.
Watch: Joshua Swain on this question in LYSSA Episode 2: "If a machine made it, who bled for it?"
If you use AI, say so
Label it. "AI illustration" in the caption or the image description.
Keep people real. Don't generate faces for testimonials, reviews or results.
Tell the client. Agree in writing which parts of a job are AI-made.
Keep the files. Save the prompts and the originals with the job.
Real people vs AI, on camera
Questions
Do consumers trust AI-generated ads?
They want to know when AI is used. In Getty Images' research nearly 90% want disclosure, and 98% say authentic images and video are pivotal to trust.
Can I use AI images in beauty advertising in the UK?
Not in a way that exaggerates what the product does. The ASA has told brands and influencers not to use filters that exaggerate a beauty product's effect, and the same thinking applies to AI retouching.
When is AI imagery a good choice?
For moodboards, concept frames, backgrounds and illustrations of objects or places, clearly labelled. Faces, skin and product results should be real.
How can photographers prove their work is real?
Behind-the-scenes footage, full team credits, original RAW files with metadata, and a consistent body of work.
Sources
Work with SwainUK
Planning a shoot like this?
Commercial film and photography in London and Dubai: concept, crew, lighting, shoot and edit, from one team.








